Skip to content
Interface language
Economic Policy Institute Education·(Date only in original)Featured

The U.S. teacher pay gap remains large: how was 25.2% calculated?

The teacher pay penalty remained high in 2025: Teachers and students nationwide are still paying the price of decades of neglect

Topic illustration of education researchers examining charts and notes
Topic illustration · not an event photograph
Reading guide

English translation

The Economic Policy Institute used Bureau of Labor Statistics data to estimate that in 2025, weekly wages for U.S. public school teachers were 25.2% below those of comparable college graduates. After employer-paid benefits are included, the estimated total compensation gap was 14.5%. These are adjusted differences between occupational groups; they do not show the causal gain an individual would receive by changing careers.

Why read this

A closer look at an older report’s methods: how wage, benefit and geographic definitions shape discussion of the teacher workforce. The estimates can be compared with recruitment and retention data.

Sources and editorial checks

Editorial check:

Source type
Report
Scope
The report analyzes public school teachers and labor force data in the United States.
Study design
Regression-adjusted weekly wages from CPS-ORG combined with employer benefit-cost data from the National Compensation Survey (NCS).
Population and context
U.S. public elementary and secondary school teachers and other college graduates aged 18–64 with a bachelor’s degree or higher who work full time.
Sample
The report does not provide a single combined sample size in the passages reviewed.
Intervention and comparison
A comparison of weekly wages for teachers and other college graduates, controlling for factors including age, education and state of residence.
Main findings
The estimated wage gap was 25.2% in 2025, while the total compensation gap was 14.5% after benefits were included. The wage gap narrowed slightly from 26.9% in 2024.
Outcomes and uncertainty
Unobserved differences between occupations may still affect the gap. State-level estimates and benefit statistics should be interpreted separately.
Funding and conflicts of interest
A policy report by a research institute; the underlying data cited in the report come from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Limitations

  • Occupational choice is not random, so these estimates cannot establish the earnings gain an individual would receive by changing careers.
  • The 2025 data omit October because of the federal government shutdown.
  • Wages and total compensation are different measures. Applying the estimates across countries requires attention to institutional differences.

Editorial analysis

Original analysis based on the sources listed. Research findings, policy goals, and editorial judgment are identified separately; original rights remain with their sources.

What the teacher “pay penalty” measures—and what it can tell us

A report released by the U.S. Economic Policy Institute on August 25, 2026, estimated that in 2025 the weekly wage gap between U.S. public school teachers and comparable college graduates was 25.2%. The figure is striking and easy to misuse. It does not mean “every teacher earns 25.2% less,” does not compare teachers with a simple average of all other workers, and is not a direct causal estimate of schools’ hiring difficulties. To understand the measure, start with who was included in the sample, which wage measure was used, and how benefits and state-level differences were handled.

Methods and comparison group

The report used the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Current Population Survey Outgoing Rotation Group, selecting workers aged 18–64 who worked at least 35 hours a week and had at least a bachelor’s degree. The teacher group consisted of public elementary and secondary school teachers; the comparison group consisted of other employed college graduates. The study used weekly rather than hourly or annual wages, in part to avoid treating summer-break arrangements as differences in the value of work in a given week. To improve comparability, the regression model controlled for factors including age, education and state of residence. Wages were based on respondents’ direct reports; wages imputed by the government when respondents did not report them were excluded. Because the original data cap high incomes, the researchers adjusted the cap using a statistical distribution. Each step affects the measure, so the final percentage should not be repeated without explaining the sample and methods.

A second data source was the Employer Costs for Employee Compensation survey. The authors included benefits such as health and life insurance, retirement plans and payroll taxes in total compensation, estimating a 14.5% total compensation gap for 2025. This is a different measure from the 25.2% wage gap, so the two figures do not contradict each other. Teachers’ relatively better benefits narrow the total compensation gap. However, the benefit estimate uses broader occupational classifications and is not a person-by-person match between each teacher and a worker in an equivalent job.

What changes the report observes

The authors estimated a wage gap of 26.9% in 2024 and 25.2% in 2025. The gap narrowed slightly but remained far above the 6.1% estimate for 1996. In inflation-adjusted weekly wages, public school teachers’ wages fell 6.2% over roughly three decades while those of other college graduates rose 28.8%. State estimates for 2025 ranged from 10.4% in Rhode Island to 40.7% in Colorado, showing how a national average can conceal differences in local labor markets, institutions and occupational composition. The report concludes that teacher pay has remained weak relative to that of other college graduates over the long term. It also proposes policies such as increased public education funding and stronger collective bargaining. The former is a descriptive statistic and model estimate; the latter is the authors’ policy recommendation. They should be read separately.

What cannot be inferred directly from the figures

The comparison groups were not randomly assigned. People who choose teaching may differ from people who choose other occupations in career preferences, fields of study, experience, location and family arrangements, including in ways the model does not fully capture. Statistical controls improve comparability, but they do not turn occupational choice into an experiment. The 25.2% estimate therefore cannot be read as meaning that “the same person would earn 25.2% more by changing careers.” Weekly wages also do not fully represent annual work hours, lesson preparation outside class or work during school breaks. Nor do they directly measure job stress, career satisfaction or student learning. The report notes that federal government shutdowns left October out of the 2025 annual data. State comparisons should also be read with attention to sample sizes and intervals; rankings alone do not warrant strong conclusions about an individual state.

Implications for education practice

For school leaders and policy discussions, the report’s main value is a relative wage measure tracked over many years with a reasonably consistent definition. It can help frame follow-up questions: Which regions or subject areas have the greatest recruitment difficulties? How are wages and benefits changing together? Is retention among new teachers affected? Are students’ opportunities to learn from stable teaching staff distributed unevenly? Answering these questions requires data on recruitment, attrition, vacancies and student outcomes; the wage gap alone cannot stand in for them. Readers outside the United States should be especially careful not to transfer U.S. pay structures mechanically to other countries. Differences in pensions, school employment systems and teachers’ working hours can change total compensation comparisons. The report is a policy report from a research institute. Its methods are public, but it is not a randomized trial and is not the same as a peer-reviewed journal article. It can serve as a starting point for studying teacher labor conditions, followed by checks of local pay systems and workforce evidence.

Readers should therefore consider this estimate alongside local teacher vacancies, turnover rates and school budgets, while stating the year and comparison measure.

Source: Economic Policy Institute Education · epi.org