How should universities assess the investment in teaching competitions? A researcher raises questions
In tighter financial times, the hidden waste in teaching competitions deserves closer attention

English translation
Writing in China Science Daily, Lu Xiaodong, a researcher at Peking University's Graduate School of Education, questions the relationship between preparation for teaching competitions, performative teaching and real classrooms. He cites preparation time, externally hired support and expert assessments from a post-competition survey of vocational institutions' teaching-skills competitions. The commentary is sharply critical, but its arguments and the scope of the cited data must be distinguished. It does not establish that every teaching competition is ineffective or produces the same degree of waste.
The commentary places university teacher-development activities in the context of time, spending and real teaching outcomes, while retaining the boundaries of the author's views and the survey he cites.
Sources and editorial checks
Editorial check:
- Scope
- The commentary discusses teaching-competition systems at Peking University and Chinese vocational institutions and was published in China Science Daily.
Limitations
- The survey figures are the author's account of a post-competition survey of vocational teaching competitions. The commentary page does not provide the full research report.
- The author's judgements about the value of teaching competitions are opinions, not empirical conclusions about the effects of every competition.
Source: China Science Daily / ScienceNet · wap.sciencenet.cn